The Complex Relationship Between Marijuana and Opioid Use
Written on
The Rise of Opioid Overdoses
The United States faces a significant crisis with narcotic addiction, highlighted by a staggering 12.9-fold increase in opioid overdose fatalities from 2007 to 2017. While a majority of these deaths stem from non-prescription narcotics, many experts suggest that the uptick in opioid prescriptions has contributed to the growing rates of illicit drug use. In response, various states are exploring alternative solutions, with medical marijuana frequently proposed as a potential remedy.
The Argument for Medical Marijuana
Advocates for medical marijuana contend that legalizing it as a pain relief option could lead to reduced opioid consumption and consequently, fewer overdose deaths. This perspective isn't entirely unfounded. Research indicates that states permitting medical or recreational marijuana tend to issue fewer opioid prescriptions. Numerous studies support marijuana's efficacy as a pain alleviator. Although marijuana is addictive, it does not typically create the same physical dependency seen with opioids, and no fatalities from marijuana overdose have been recorded, making it a comparatively safer option.
However, these claims come with important qualifications. As highlighted in the research linking marijuana legalization with opioid prescription rates, there are limitations inherent in observational studies. This means we cannot definitively prove a causal relationship between the two.
Conflicting Research Findings
Proponents of medical marijuana received a boost in 2014 from a study published in JAMA Internal Medicine, which indicated that states with legalized medical marijuana experienced a 24.8% decrease in opioid-related deaths compared to those without such laws. This finding gained significant attention in both academic and mainstream media, leading to an increase in studies investigating marijuana's role in managing chronic pain and combating opioid addiction.
Nevertheless, subsequent research has cast doubt on the initial conclusions. A recent study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences reevaluated the findings of the 2014 research, extending the analysis over a longer time frame. The results revealed that states with medical marijuana regulations actually showed a 22.7% increase in opioid-related overdose deaths compared to states without such laws.
Interpreting the Discrepancies
These conflicting outcomes raise the question: how do we reconcile these differing results? It's easy to jump to conclusions and suggest that one research team made an error, particularly if the findings align with pre-existing biases. However, this is unlikely, as both studies utilized the same data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and employed comparable statistical methods.
The disparity in results can be attributed to the volume of data each research team analyzed. The first study noted a consistent decline in opioid deaths following the legalization of medical marijuana; however, the second study found that this trend plateaued and even reversed after 2013. Thus, while both studies interpreted their findings correctly, the first group lacked sufficient data to identify the underlying trends.
What Lies Ahead for Medical Marijuana and Opioid Addiction?
The implications of these studies on the relationship between marijuana legalization and opioid addiction remain complex. If a connection exists, it is likely indirect and minimal in impact. The researchers considered several other factors, such as unemployment rates and state laws concerning opioid monitoring, but many potential variables were not taken into account. Additionally, only about 2.5% of the general population uses marijuana regularly, suggesting that such a small demographic is unlikely to significantly influence overall opioid mortality rates.
Ultimately, the simplest explanation may be that the two phenomena are unrelated. The studies highlight correlations rather than causations, and it is essential to avoid conflating the two, particularly in discussions influenced by media narratives surrounding contentious topics. Critics of marijuana are likely to leverage the second study's findings as evidence that marijuana serves as a "gateway drug" exacerbating the opioid crisis. This scenario underscores the necessity for ongoing research and responsible reporting in this field.
Further Insights on Cannabis and Health
Is Cannabis Putting Your Bones At Risk?
Research from the University of Edinburgh indicates potential risks associated with cannabis use...
About the Author
- Brandon Lowry, PhD, from the Institute of Molecular Biology at the University of Oregon, is a digital nomad and freelance writer. He covers topics related to cannabis, science, health, and travel, and serves as the assistant editor at Midnight Mosaic Fiction.