Emerging Insights: Society's Evolving Relationship with Social Media
Written on
Chapter 1: The Cultural Impact of Digital Technologies
Cultural understanding of technology's effects often develops more slowly than we think. The rise of digital technologies, particularly the internet and its enabling tools, brought social media crashing into our lives nearly two decades ago.
With over fifteen years of research into social media's influence on both businesses and public policy, it appears we're entering a crucial phase of transformation in our engagement with these platforms. Why is this noteworthy?
This situation mirrors historical trends within sociocultural systems regarding technology. Initially, groundbreaking innovations shape culture significantly. As society gains insight into the social ramifications of these technologies, there tends to be a reciprocal reshaping of the technology itself.
We often mistakenly believe that technological revolutions occur instantaneously. This misconception is fueled by commentators who misinterpret the adoption patterns of new technologies.
Consider claims about ChatGPT's rapid user adoption, reportedly reaching 57 million users in a month, or the swift uptake of Threads. Such statements can be misleading.
User registration numbers do not reflect a true cultural shift. For instance, while ChatGPT's usage has fluctuated, this inconsistency is not the primary focus of our discussion.
Section 1.1: A New Perspective on Social Media
When social media first emerged, many Western leaders envisioned a future filled with democracy and freedom. However, the reality has often contrasted sharply with these predictions.
Nonetheless, social media has also played a role in significant societal movements, such as MeToo and Black Lives Matter. This duality illustrates the complexities inherent in all technologies.
Subsection 1.1.1: Understanding the Current Landscape
Reflecting on my past research with international organizations like the United Nations and NGOs such as Freedom House, I see emerging indicators of change, especially in light of current conflicts like the Israeli-Hamas war.
There is a noticeable shift in how citizens are engaging with information—researching topics and applying critical thinking skills rather than reacting impulsively. This awareness extends to a societal understanding of misinformation's role in shaping narratives, both by state and non-state actors.
Like consumers who have learned to overlook online advertisements, people are becoming more discerning regarding social media content.
Section 1.2: Cultural Reactions to Misuse of Social Media
Western governments have repeatedly highlighted how autocratic regimes, such as those in Iran, Russia, and China, manipulate social media to influence elections. This trend reflects a broader cultural reaction to the ways social media can be weaponized to sow division.
Human societies utilize culture—including political and economic systems, art, and traditions—to evolve and determine how technologies should integrate into our lives.
We're witnessing a growing pushback from citizens and governmental bodies against the manipulative tactics employed by some social media platforms. Recent bipartisan lawsuits against Meta and changes in EU digital laws illustrate this trend.
Chapter 2: A Possible Sociocultural Shift
The first video titled "Is Social Media Good or Bad for Society?" explores the dual nature of social media's effects on modern life, highlighting both positive and negative impacts.
The second video "Is Social Media Really Ruining Our Lives? (ft. Jonathan Haidt)" offers insights from experts on the psychological and societal implications of social media use.
While quantitative data collection is challenging in this field, qualitative approaches suggest a potential shift in societal attitudes toward social media. This could indicate an emerging trend, although time will reveal its permanence.
If such a shift is indeed occurring, it signifies a sociocultural transformation. Although we cannot predict its outcome, history provides valuable lessons. Just as regulations around pharmaceuticals and food safety emerged to protect public health, similar standards for social media could safeguard mental health, privacy, and freedoms.
Translating the rule of law and cultural norms from the physical realm to the digital landscape has proven difficult. This challenge is not solely the fault of governments, tech giants, or society at large; it stems from a collective misunderstanding of how social media would evolve and influence our lives.
Adopting revolutionary technologies has always been a complex, often chaotic process. We may be witnessing the beginnings of a sociocultural shift that could impose pressure on social media companies to adapt to societal expectations. If we are increasingly critical of the information presented to us on these platforms, it signals a healthy cultural evolution—a system working as intended.
Unlike those who proclaimed a new era of democracy following the advent of social media, I won't make sweeping predictions. However, the currents of change are palpable, and the path ahead may become increasingly turbulent as ideologies and behaviors clash.